It infringed three design patents and two utility patents awarded to Apple to cover early models of its popular smartphone. The devices over which it was sued are no longer on sale and yet the case has dragged on since then but lawsuits and countersuits being filed by both companies.
Attorneys for Apple, however, said the jury should award some $1 billion to the iPhone maker based on overall sales of Samsung's devices. Samsung disputed the amount and now the fight is over the amount that's due to the Cupertino company.
Apple and Samsung are facing each other in a California court for a third trial involving the same set of five patents.
In its latest trial, Apple has the burden of proof to prove that Samsung should pay the full $1 billion in damages.
The conundrum for jurors: Are damages based on "the whole phone, kit and caboodle, or just the shell of the phone - into which Samsung put a bunch of stuff that's unrelated to the patent?"
Samsung had objected to the size of the design patent portion of the existing penalty, which had been determined by how much profit it had made from selling the handsets. "This is the article of manufacture", Quinn said of the components.
Apple lawyer Bill Lee told jurors this week that their sole objective was to determine what damages the company should collect.
Apple is seeking profits which have been made on the entire phone. And the Supreme Court ordered the U.S. Court of Appeals to redetermine the value Samsung owes Apple for the design patent violation, which directs to the trial that's happening this week. The jury will have to decide if the Supreme Court's caveat applies to the current case, or if Apple's characterization of the matter is more correct. Morrison & Foerster partner Harold McElhinny, who once played the leading role for Apple, has retired and partner Rachel Krevans, who also represented the Cupertino, California-based company died a year ago. Expert Michael Wagner is expected to offer evidence of how much Apple spends on items such as screen glass to help calculate damages.
Had Apple not released the iPhone, it anxious that mobile carriers could easily make the iPod obsolete by adding music to their phones, which served as a "gigantic threat" to the company and its mainstay media player.
Anne then attempts to explain sex to an imaginary person, using the information she's learnt from her father, a friend and books. Researchers in the Dutch capital have recovered two pages from one of Anne Frank's diaries that contain passages on sexuality.
Real Madrid stars Cristiano Ronaldo and Dani Carvajal returned to full training on Tuesday afternoon with their teammates. It would be a huge blow for everyone. "Besides, it would make Madrid stronger than they are".
Mary McWilliams of San Clemente tells the Orange County Register that she saw two women with burns stagger out of the building. Two of the injured people had unknown injuries, and the third person suffered smoke-inhalation, according to officials .
This week, WWE is in London and the two remaining spots from Team Red will be filled after a couple more qualifying matches. Finn Balor & Braun Strowman by Dolph Ziggler pinning Finn Balor after knocking Finn Balor off of the top rope.
When an update is successfully installed, users will receive a notification on their Android phone, according to CNET . That'll no longer be an issue with today's update: You can set a double tap on the right earbud to skip tracks.
Police investigators say they'll take all the time they need to find and convict the killer of Rachael DelTondo . Authorities then drove the student home, and informed DelTondo that there were "better places to just talk".
The creator of the viral sensation spoke out and sorry to say " Yanny " listeners, he confirmed he said " Laurel ". The different things we hear reminds us that our world, and ourselves, are far more unknown than we think.
Raazi is reportedly an adaptation of Harinder Sikka's Calling Sehmat . "He wrote, " #Raazi shows EXCELLENT HOLD on Monday . Bollywood trade analyst Taran Adarsh took it to micro-blogging site Twitter to share the box office collection of Raazi .
A late goal in the second period from Brett Connolly and another from Evgeny Kuznetsov in the third made it interesting. Even with the horrendous calls in the first period of Game 2, the Caps prevailed, and it wasn't even close.
Tepper, age 60, has risen to be one of the world's richest hedge-fund managers since he founded Appaloosa Management in 1993. This deal comes six months after Richardson put the team up for sale amidst allegations of workplace misconduct.
Latest 2018 Preakness Stakes odds
Bravazo was the third longest shot at the Kentucky Derby a few weeks ago, but surprised everyone by placing sixth in that race. With rain expected in Baltimore through Saturday, the conditions at Pimlico may not be much better.
Solo: A Star Wars Story is a Missed Opportunity
Vanity Fair said Solo is likely not the movie Lord And Miller would have made, but said Howard's version "knows its place". Jackson's Mace Windu, and Billy Dee Williams's Lando Calrissian .
Senate Approves Measure to Reinstate Net Neutrality
Senator Ed Markey of MA argued that " net neutrality is the free speech issue of our time", according toArs Technica. If that does manage to happen, the net neutrality rules the FCC enacted in 2015 would not be repealed next month.
Tennessee, 5 other states suing opioid maker Purdue Pharma
They allege the pharmaceutical company and opioid manufacturer played a leading role in the opioid epidemic in the Mid-South. Stamford, Connecticut-based Purdue, in a statement, denied the accusations, saying its drugs were approved by the U.S.
Lewis Hamilton wins the 2018 Spanish GP
This is the type of race that reminds spectators and drivers alike that Hamilton still has unrivaled pace. "Let's keep this up". Hamilton is now standing at the top spot in the drivers' championship, maintaining a lead of just four points over Vettel.